Liner Vinyl

Made my eye red for three days

Not good. So, of course the color stays on very well, the pencil is very hard to use, but the reason why I give it one star is that I slept with it overnight (yeah... I know....I shouldn't but I do it a lot )and it left the corner of my eye red for three days. I've used all the products you can (from cheap to crazy expensive) and none did that.

Disappointed

It was not very pigmented so it did not show up very well. The applicator brush was not capable of thin or careful lines. Additionally, the liner easily smeared and 'caked' off throughout the day.

Awesome

I love this eyeliner because it has a real brush, not felt tip, and plenty of liner so it doesn't skip. It was confusing at first because the short part of the bottle is the part where the liquid is, and the long part is the length of the brush. So you don't get as much product as the bottle would suggest (*tricky). However, mine has lasted me months

I was looking for a long lasting waterproof black eyeliner with a BRUSH applicator and I really hoped that this would work out for me. But unfortunately, this liner is not long lasting and i really did not like the formula. The liquid liner is clumpy and you can't apply this eyeliner in one stroke. Sadly, there aren't many liquid eyeliners with a brush tip out there.

Dries out and thickens after a few uses

Ugh, don't waste your money. This one starts out good and ends terribly. It goes on perfectly thick and very dark and looks fabulous. However, it dries up and gets chunky and hard to apply after a few uses. The cap never seems to tighten enough and the product dries out quickly and becomes useless. I am NOT a girl who wears 3 lbs of makeup so I don't go through eyeliner like water. If you do, you may have better luck than me, but I have found other eyeliners last me months and never dry out. This ISN'T one of them.

It became hard too early

I like this one a lot, I am used to liquid eyeliner and the brush and it’s too late for me to learn to apply other kinds :p It doesn’t smudge or tear in pieces. But it started to harden too early, after a month of use(not every day) it’s almost like a paste now, and it becomes hard to apply with the thin brush... :(

Love it!

Love it! The brush glides over lid well to create a beautiful cat eye. It stays put for a 12 hour workday w/out flaking or wearing off. Expensive, but worth it!

Wow

So I've been looking for glossy, shiny looking liquid liner for a while and tried different things. This has been the best so far. It is a bit on the watery side, meaning if you get it in your eyes it stings and goes everywhere. But the brush is good for applying, an actual brush not felt or anything else. The one thing I would warn about is the packaging is deceiving. You might think the long part of the wand is eyeliner product, but the actual product is in the short end of the tube. I thought that was sneaky but overall its a good product, you're just not getting as much as you think. It IS glossy so it does what it says.

LOVE

Easy to use. I got the black one and it is REAL dark black not the likely black fades one. I used to love YSL eye liner before but this one is the winner now. Love it.

This is my FAVORITE liquid eyeliner EVER!

I do not make impulse purchases! I tried this on at the store & wore the liner everywhere I went for the rest of my day -- at least six times before I broke down and purchased it. So I already knew it was my favorite liquid eyeliner ever (and I like liquid eyeliners the BEST!). I usually draw on my cat-eye with a pencil or a wet-brush powder eyeshadow FIRST, to check my placements for everything. Then I set the whole shebang with THIS, and it always comes out PERFECT. NO migration onto my eyelid or cheek EVER, not ever! All in all, this is a perfect product. P.S. If you ever find you have trouble removing stuff like this from your face, TRY MICELLAR WATER. You can even scrub your eyelashes with it -- it DOES NOT STING your eyes and it absolutely washes your face as clean as a daisy. And it leaves your face mildly moisturized & ready to accept your skin care products! Without using any other toner whatsoever! Sephora sells several brands of micellar water, they're all good.

I did not care for this liquid mascara. It was very difficult applying. I could never get a straight line. I will return this product

LOVE THIS LINER

I love this liquid eyeliner. It is so easy to use and lasts all night!